Naturally, I Assumed...

From AIOWiki
(Redirected from Naturally, I Assumed)
Jump to: navigation, search
#260: “Naturally, I Assumed...”
Date Recorded
Recorded at
Cassette No.
[[:Category:Episodes with {{{intro}}} intro| {{{intro}}}]]
Click to show or hide ↓
  • [[:Category:Episodes with {{{intro}}} intro| {{{intro}}}]]
[[:Category:Episodes with {{{wraps}}} wraps| {{{wraps}}}]]
Click to show or hide ↓
  • [[:Category:Episodes with {{{wraps}}} wraps| {{{wraps}}}]]
Philippians 4:8
8Finally, brothers, whatever is true, whatever is noble, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is admirable--if anything is excellent or praiseworthy--think about such things.
Songs By
Inventions Used
Shorts Used


Current user rating: 91/100 (40 votes)

 You need to enable JavaScript to vote

Written by
Directed by
Produced by
Executive Producer
Post-Production by
Engineered by
Music by
The Potential in Elliot
Naturally, I Assumed...
“Naturally, I Assumed...” is episode #260 of the Adventures in Odyssey audio series. It was written and directed by Paul McCusker, and originally aired on February 19, 1994.


Eugene begins to suspect Katrina Shanks may not share the same feelings for him as he does for her, when he finds out she's been hanging out with a mysterious 'Darren McGibbs.'


Connie's curiosity is getting the best of her again. She tells Whit that Eugene has been acting strangely lately. He leaves just before four o’clock every day so he can race to the college. Whit says that’s natural, Eugene is going to class. But Connie knows better. It isn’t school Eugene is thinking about, it’s Katrina. Sure enough, just then, Eugene speeds by on his way out the door. Connie teases Eugene as he leaves, then decides to find out how his relationship with Katrina is progressing.

As it turns out, Eugene is having a slight problem. Eugene really likes Katrina, but she hasn’t given him any sign that the feelings are mutual. In fact, she tells Eugene that she can no longer meet at their usual time. She has another appointment and doesn’t want to keep him waiting.

Eugene is understandably upset about having to vie for Katrina’s affections. Connie coaxes the whole story out of him and immediately takes Eugene under her wing. She offers Eugene all sorts of suggestions about what girls like: small gifts, romantic language, flowers, candy. Eugene tries them all, with comically disastrous results. To make matters worse, Whit walks in on Connie and Eugene several times at the wrong moments. Soon Whit begins to think romance is brewing between his two employees!

Finally, Katrina discloses that her mysterious appointment is with a young boy from England named Darren. Katrina is tutoring him. The merry mix-up is solved, and everyone is reminded of why it is foolish to make assumptions.

This plot section is too short and should be expanded. »

Discussion Questions

  1. Should Eugene have told Katrina how he felt about her?
    • Why or why not?
    • How could he have shared his feelings?
  2. How could all of these misunderstandings have been avoided?
  3. Why should you never assume things about people?
    • Have you assumed anything about anyone lately?


Role Voice Actor
Connie Kendall Katie Leigh
Darren McGibbs Matt Butcher
Eugene Meltsner Will Ryan
John Whittaker Hal Smith
Katrina Shanks Pamela Hayden



Connie Kendall: Look, you're a boy, which naturally means you don't know the first thing about girls. I'm a girl, which...
Eugene Meltsner: Which naturally means you know everything there is to know about boys and girls!
Connie Kendall: Right!
Eugene Meltsner: What?!

Katrina Shanks: Now, would you care to explain what that tirade was all about?
Connie Kendall:, it was nothing; lines from a play I'm working on. It's called "The Large Foot Deep Into the Mouth."